It was New Year’s eve, and the engineer was chewing the cud. Mentally, that is. His better half was peacefully watching television in the living room, and he was sitting with a book, staring into emtpy space. He’d gotten a new job, and had to shift base shortly.
The telephone rang, and the TV muted itself out, thanks to a thoughtful thumb jabbing at the remote. Squeezing his eyes shut and making a moue to convey his unspoken gratitude, the engineer picked up the phone.
Hello
Hello, Son
Hi Dad, it’s good to hear your voice
(Dad says nothing, smiles at the other end.)
So, son, when do you have to join up at work?
On the 12th, Dad
But that’s a bad day – it’s the eighth day after the new moon, and you know you aren’t supposed to start anything on either the eighth or ninth days.
I’m Sorry, Dad – you know I don’t believe in these things
(A hurt silence at the other end)
It’s all right son, perhaps you’ll realize certain things as you grow up
I’m old enough, Dad
(After an uncomfortable pause, the conversation moves over to more pleasant topics, and ends.)
The engineer is a little piqued, a little saddened, and a little confused.
Is it a crime to live your life, learn from your experiences, and then add to your understanding of the world around you, rather than to blindly believe in what your ancestors believed in? Is it right to hurt someone by holding on to your beliefs which are different from theirs? Is it right to be hurt because someone you care for might have beliefs different from yours? is it a crime to question accepted beliefs?
There are no easy answers to these questions. One might be tempted to say, hey look, it’s just a harmless matter of dates, so moving the date aside to please your parent is OK. Maybe. What should one do when the discussion involves the caste system, and you’re both on opposite sides of the fence? What if you’re in love with someone who doesn’t belong to your caste, and your parents don’t want you to marry this person – only because he or she belongs to a different caste? For that matter, how does one react when Baba Ramdev claims that his flavour of yoga can cure Multiple Sclerosis, AIDS and Cancer? Or when a loved one claims belief in a particular swami’s powers when you believe that the godman is a fake?
In the end, it seems to come down to a question of blind belief at one end versus unbridled skepticism at the other. Should there be a distinction between accepted belief and proven fact? Why go one way and not the other? We shall save the visit to Richard Dawkins land for another day.